John Chidley A blog about reading, writing, pop culture and sports.


Graphic Novel Review: Captain America: Winter Soldier vol. 1 & 2

Captain America: Winter Soldier vol. 2

One of my New Year’s resolutions was to read more comic books and graphic novels. Hardly a self-improvement project, I know, but I want to get down with my nerd self.

My first graphic novel of 2010 is Captain America: Winter Soldier vol. 2, allowing me to complete the first story arc of Ed Brubaker’s popular run on one of Marvel Comics’ most recognizable characters.

I’ve never been much of a Captain America fan. I prefer grittier characters like Batman or the Punisher, so his squeaky clean image never appealed to me. And since I’m Canadian, all the patriotic beats were lost on me.

But Brubaker’s Winter Soldier storyline sucked me in. I’d heard that the new Captain America series was going to be bringing back Bucky, a character who had been dead since the end of World War II, and it hooked me.

This was a Big Deal to comic fans. Bucky had been Cap’s 16-year-old sidekick during the war, but was tragically killed when a missile he was trying to disarm exploded in mid-flight. The same incident dropped Cap into the frigid North Sea, freezing him until the 1960s.

The death of Bucky had always been cited as the reason why Marvel’s superheroes don’t have teenaged sidekicks - unlike their DC counterparts - and it added a sense of realism to the company’s mythos.

For Brubaker to be retconning a fundamental element of Marvel Comics seemed like heresy, albeit an intriguing act of rebellion.

Captain America: Winter Soldier Book One and Two brings together issues 1-14 of the fifth monthly series to star Steve Rogers. They revolve around a terrorist attack that was apparently perpetrated by a mythical Cold Warrior known as the Winter Soldier who may actually be Cap’s former partner Bucky.

Resurrection storylines have become commonplace in comics, a constant recycling of characters who had been killed for dramatic effect, only to return. It’s a trend that is holding back a medium that I love. But Brubaker handles the return of the long-dead hero with a deft hand that provides not just a plausible explanation for his survival, but an engrossing story.

Interspersed with action, character moments and plot developments, Winter Soldier begins with Captain America becoming angry and frustrated with the inability of the United States government to attack countries that sponsor terrorism. The detonation of a Weapon of Mass Destruction in Philadelphia leaves a trail that leads to former Soviet general Aleksander Lukin, and his shadowy operative the Winter Soldier.

Even the name Winter Soldier is clever work by Brubaker. It’s a reference to the loyal American revolutionaries who stuck with George Washington over the harrowing winter in Valley Forge, but also to the Winter Soldier Investigation, a Viet Nam era examination of atrocities and war crimes committed by the United States Armed Forces.

Brubaker seamlessly connects the Second World War, the Cold War, modern terrorism and Captain America’s complex continuity. It’s not just that he brings in plot points from every era of Cap’s 70 years of existence, but the pacing and style of the book draws heavily on these aspects of the character’s history.

To me, a classic Captain America story has him and a partner rushing off into danger to stop a catastrophe from befalling the United States or the world. Winter Soldier is no different, with Cap rushing to stop Kronas Corporation with the Falcon  riding shotgun.

Steve Epting’s art work in this series is fantastic. I can’t think of a current comics creator who makes better use of inking and colouring techniques. His characters are expressive and natural in conversation, and dynamic and fun during action scenes.

In particular, the way he draws the acrobatic Captain America jumping, rolling and bouncing in fight scenes is thrilling.

Winter Soldier breaks an old comic fan saying: “No one stays dead, except Bucky and Uncle Ben.” The phrase refers to the fact that Peter Parker’s uncle and Captain America’s sidekick must stay dead because their loss is what, in part, forms the hero we know today.

I never thought I’d see the day where that axiom was successfully reversed, but the Winter Soldier saga does it.

The return of James “Bucky” Buchanan Barnes was enough to catch my interest and buy the first volume of Captain America: Winter Soldier, and the gripping story has lead me to the rest of the series. Brubaker’s writing isn’t some gimmick. It’s some of the best mainstream superhero comic work I’ve ever read.

Comments (4) Trackbacks (1)
  1. A refreshing read. The only books I’m reading at the moment are Blackest Night, Green Lantern, Green Lantern Corps and Batman & Robin. Civil War and it’s aftershocks more or less killed any love I had for Marvel, so I’m happy to hear they are still producing some decent work.

  2. I fell in love with Cap the first time I saw him; Episode 12 of Spider Man and his Amazing Friends (“Pawns of the Kingpin”). I was a child at the time, so his politics meant nothing to me. I just thought he was so cool. This man dressed in red, white and blue; with a shield, and a bunch of acrobatic moves.

    I think the first time I read a comic with Cap was an issue where he fought Batroc the Leaper. I remember nothing about the issue, but later on I would read Secret Wars, and I believe it was here that he would be cemented as a favorite in the Boothe Hall of Heroes. No powers (serum doesn’t count here), but still earning the trust and respect of Earth’s mightiest heroes and villains.

    Of course my (and many others) favorite Cap moment was when he stood face to face with Thanos in the Infinity Gauntlet mini series. A definite classic Marvel moment.

    I took a lot of flack from my X-friends for liking the Avengers family of comics. Overshadowed by the Claremont/Byrne/Silvestri/Jim Lee eras of X-Books, they were seen as lame by many of my friends. I stood by them though, mostly due to my love of Captain America, but also because a lot of their stories felt a lot more old school, and a little less convoluted.

    Definitely not hating on the X, though. A lot of great stories came out of that end of the Marvel Universe.

  3. Also…I was extremely impressed by Steve Epting’s work in the latest Captain America series.

    I loved his covers during his Avengers run, but was never blown away by the interior art. I remember being very happy when he was replaced by Mike Deodato Jr. (his female characters were sexy :-D)

    Look at Steve now!

  4. Wow! Well written. You are a genius! Couldn’t open your resume or writing samples, though. Are PWAC meetings at night? If so, could you be available to attend them?
    Again — brilliant!

Leave a comment